John Robbie a Mampara?

I was surprised to see 702 morning presenter John Robbie named the week’s “Mampara” by the Sunday Times in their big exclusive Manto edition on Sunday. At first I was amused, then perplexed as I read through it.

We could laugh it off and one could dismiss the Mampara Award as nothing but light humour and satire, but it is taken seriously by many. I can think of a hundred more deserving people who the Mampara award could go to before John Robbie. In fact I don’t think he is Mampara material at all. Previous winners of the award include thieves, murderers, racists and despots. Zimbabwe’s despotic president Robert Mugabe is a regular Mampara. So it’s not hard to see that Robbie seems very out of place here.

In his morning show the next day on Monday, Robbie didn’t take a swipe at the Sunday Times. He admitted the label was “hurtful” and that he was “a bit down” as a result of his new award. While admitting that as a high profile radio presenter he was fair game, he felt this particular Mampara writ had a “personal” edge to it.

I have to agree with Robbie. Also, much of what was said was just simply not accurate, including the descriptions that he is “one of the dullest windbags ever to mug the airwaves” and “tired and unimaginative”. Call Robbie many things, but I doubt anyone — even his detractors — would describe him as “dull” or “unimaginative”. In fact Robbie is often criticised for getting a little too passionate and hot-headed at times.

I had listened to his show the previous week where he had criticised the Sunday Times — and I also disagreed with Robbie’s statements. I felt the Sunday Time’s story was newsworthy because it involved a public official in high office, but agreed with Robbie in that those were good questions to ask and debate. From a Sunday Times point of view, it was worth contesting, but hardly worth branding Robbie a Mampara.

It misses the mark for me.

Comments (3)

  1. Duncan McLeod wrote::

    Have to agree, Matt. John Robbie is the best thing on breakfast radio in South Africa. If Hogarth is looking for a dull windbag he should tune into Highveld Stereo in the mornings.

    Monday, August 20, 2007 at 10:09 pm #
  2. matt wrote::

    LOL — agree on that one.

    Tuesday, August 21, 2007 at 9:45 am #
  3. Jayne Morgan wrote::

    I completely agree. If you’re going to go for gratuitous insults, at least make them relevant to your target. John Robbie is one of the best things on radio in this country – most importantly because he actually asks difficult questions. If he had resorted to the same kind of vindictiveness on the air as the ST did on their pages, he would quite rightly have been chastised by the station and its listeners. Good talk show hosts are employed to have an opinion and not be afraid to express it – which is what he did. And when it comes to windbags, perhaps the Sunday Times could cast an eye over some of its own pages … or, indeed, columnists.

    Tuesday, August 21, 2007 at 10:57 am #